Politic

Malaysian Bar Challenges Najib Razak's House Arrest, Seeks Court Order to Suspend Arrangement

· kepohub Newsroom
Malaysian Bar Challenges Najib Razak's House Arrest, Seeks Court Order to Suspend Arrangement

KUALA LUMPUR, Nov 12 — Former Malaysian prime minister Najib Razak's house-arrest arrangement is facing a new legal challenge after the Malaysian Bar filed an application at the Kuala Lumpur High Court questioning the constitutional validity of the decision.

The application for leave to commence judicial review was filed on November 10 and challenges the Federal Territories Pardons Board's September 18 decision allowing Najib to serve the remainder of his SRC International prison sentence at home.

The matter was scheduled for hearing before High Court judge S. Indra Nehru on November 12.

The Malaysian Bar is also seeking to suspend the arrangement while the legal challenge is considered.

Fresh challenge follows Najib's return home

Najib began serving the remaining portion of his SRC International sentence at his Langgak Duta residence in Kuala Lumpur after a High Court order was issued on November 10.

The order allows him to remain under house arrest until August 23, 2028.

It also directs him to return to Kajang Prison on August 24, 2028, to serve a separate sentence connected to the 1MDB case, subject to developments in ongoing legal proceedings.

The house-arrest order followed a conditional royal pardon and payment of a RM50 million fine.

However, the Malaysian Bar's latest application raises questions about whether the underlying decision was constitutionally valid.

Constitutional provisions at the centre of dispute

The legal challenge focuses on Articles 40 and 42 of Malaysia's Federal Constitution.

Article 42 provides the constitutional framework for the exercise of royal pardon powers.

In its application, the Malaysian Bar argues that the constitutional powers relating to pardons, reprieves and reductions of punishment do not necessarily authorise the conversion of imprisonment into house arrest.

The Bar also contends that the arrangement is not expressly provided for under the criminal law framework relevant to the case.

These are arguments advanced by the applicant, not findings that the High Court has already accepted.

The court must determine whether the legal challenge may proceed and, if appropriate, consider the substantive constitutional questions.

Bar seeks to overturn Pardons Board decision

The Malaysian Bar is asking the court to declare that the procedures and decisions leading to Najib's house arrest were unlawful or unconstitutional.

It is also seeking an order to quash the relevant September 18 proceedings and decision of the Federal Territories Pardons Board.

In addition, the Bar wants implementation of the house-arrest arrangement suspended pending the outcome of judicial review, if the required permission is granted.

A request for a suspension does not itself amount to a suspension order.

The court would need to make a separate determination before the existing arrangement could be halted through the requested relief.

Four respondents named

The application names the Federal Territories Pardons Board, the Minister in the Prime Minister's Department responsible for Law and Institutional Reform, the senior prison authority and Najib as respondents.

It was filed through the law firm Amir & Rajpal Ghai.

In a supporting affidavit, Malaysian Bar secretary R. Jayabalan argued that the case raises important constitutional questions concerning the exercise of public powers and the administration of criminal justice.

The Bar also questioned whether all relevant factors had been properly considered when the house-arrest decision was made.

Those concerns remain allegations presented in court documents and have not been established by a final ruling in this new case.

Separate legal proceedings remain pending

The latest application is distinct from an earlier challenge involving the reduction of Najib's sentence and fine in 2024.

According to reports published on November 11, a decision in the Malaysian Bar's appeal relating to that earlier matter is scheduled for January 7, 2027.

The two cases concern different decisions and should not be treated as a single court proceeding.

Meanwhile, Najib's separate 1MDB conviction and sentence remain subject to appeal.

No confirmed order ending house arrest

The new filing does not automatically overturn the existing November 10 High Court order.

As of the latest reports verified for this article, there was no confirmed ruling granting the Malaysian Bar's requested stay or directing Najib to return to prison because of the new application.

The next significant development will be the court's decision on whether the judicial review may proceed and whether temporary relief is warranted.

The case is likely to remain closely watched because it raises questions about how constitutional pardon powers interact with the enforcement of criminal sentences.

#KEPOHUB #SingaporeNews #MalaysiaNews #NajibRazak #MalaysianBar #HouseArrest #JudicialReview #SRCInternational #1MDB #MalaysiaPolitics

Previous Posting